To view graphic version of this page, refresh this page (F5)

Skip to page body

Meeting Information



EnvironmentalCommittee

2009 2008 2007 2006 

MINUTES

San Francisco Asthma Task Force Environmental Committee
Wednesday, August 1st at 2-4pm, Fox Plaza, 1390 Market St., Suite 230

 

ATF Members in attendance: Neil Gendel (Healthy Children Organizing Project), Gloria Thornton (ATF/Blue Cross), Vincent Fabrice (DBI), Mary Higgins (ATF), Ray Manion (Dept of Environment)

Staff: Anjali Nath

Guests: Diana Austria (DPH), Twyn (CA Breathing), Sara Shortt (Housing Rights Committee), Sean Pritchard, Janet Tobacman (CA Breathing)

 

Agenda Item with Intended Outcome

Status

Tasks over next 30 days

Introductions

Sara Shortt, ED, Housing Rights Committee

Pritchard, SF Apartment Association

Sara Shortt is the new ED of Housing Rights Committee.  Has been there for 3 years working primarily on subsidized housing, SFHA, Section 8.

 

·          

Asthma-Safe Healthy Housing Guidance for Property Owners (Ben)

 

Clarification on scope: New and/or existing housing.  Presumed existing housing.

Ben took over where Louise left off.  Added language to sections 5 and 6. 

Need to ask Karen if should be written from property maintenance perspective (how currently written) or add new construction.

Clarified that the target audience is property owners – include mailing list for lead-based paint database.  Can also help build support.

Purpose: Educational document for property owners

 

Rosemary Bosque is Chief of Housing Inspection Program division being integrated into Housing Inspection section at DBI.

 

Karen can help us address Rajiv’s comments.  Address much more than intended.

 

Diana will receive and compile comments on the guidance.

 

Janet brought up the issue of safety.  Can we add a sentence. Something like: “Consider that residents may be fearful to open windows, therefore not getting proper ventilation.  You may want to discuss this with your tenant and see…”

 

Can make a reference to other guidance documents to help them understand gravity, importance of addressing larger issues like mold, must be done properly. 

 

Karen asked Ben to go through LEEDS documents and will do so for next meeting. Will insert some LEEDS criteria that would fit it with the grid.

 

        Clarify scope for guidance

        Contact Rosemary Bosque from DBI

        Karen to consider Rajiv’s comments on Guidance

        All will get revisions/comments/edits on guidance to Diana by Friday August 10th.

        Janet will suggest some language/a sentence to insert related to safety.

        Ben will insert some LEEDS criteria into document.

.

Update:  Public awareness re. consumer products use for healthier housing (Neil)

·         furnishings

·         cleaning products

·         bleach

Aiming to create a CAC for SF having to do with ed and outreach related to Healthy Housing. 3rd prong to Healthy Housing legislation.  Educate tenants about how to maintain their own homes. 

 

        Neil will inform Anjali/Karen about how this agenda item should be altered

Update:  SFHA Collaboration (Anjali/ Karen)

·         Agents of Change video vignette

·         Thermographic cameras/ training

·         Administering evaluation; working with CAFA Evaluation Team

·         Tenant Education and outreach

  

HRC is very interested in camera project.  Sara mentioned that they can help with tenant education.  They are expanding their counseling program for public housing residents.

Would like to see measures of success, outcomes – can help with that as well.  Anjali talked about our evaluation plans with support from CAFA Evaluation Team.

 

DBI MOU might be a model to help make MOE stronger.  Maxwell’s office is having a meeting this week to sign MOU. Re: DBI and SFHA code enforcement. Because of city atty – discovered that DBI has local jurisdiction. Outlines protocol for complaint and response process.  Sara mentioned the idea of bringing DPH inspectors into that, and outreach partners.

 

Hope SF – Mayor’s init to replace fed funding for Hope 6 (long term 10-15 years down line, major demolition, etc.)  Promise on table to provide $4M immediate repair money. Prioritizing repair needs.  Not a lot of money relatively.  Community groups are formulating priorities.   Mold keeps coming up as a common issue.

 

 

        Ask Eval team to be here or be on phone

        Anjali will email MOE to Sara and others

        Sara will email MOU

 

 

Healthy Housing Legislation

Guest: Connie Chan, Aide to Supervisor SophieMaxwell– arriving 3/3:15

Review of possible priorities grid

Review of policy recommendations

Discussion on prioritizing recommendations

Mary indicated that her top priorities were Vents and Cameras.

Discussion on Vents and windows

Might be challenging

Problem with grandfathering in of housing

Sara said they can require things for aging stock

Consider opposition

Seizmic retrofit issue – in the end didn’t get much opposition because realized important even though

 

Jent asked -What’s the threshold of work at which a new vent is put in – anything you pull a permit for.  Suggested reducing threshold once someone pulls a permit.  Members indicated not ideal because

 

Whole House Performance Testing:  pressure testing of home

Keeps air flow adequate and in the right direction, ventilation, Air Leaks, combustible,

Less expensive than camera

Code enforcement issues:

What are things not currently being addressed

What are things that need tweaking

 

Criteria/Considerations to help us prioritize issues for potential legislation:

Feasible

Has buy in

Would be a slam dunk/easy win

Cost

Opposition

Health (impact/benefits)

Which strategy would be used

Research to back it up

Want to frame issue effectively

 

After reviewing the grid a few people expressed which issues stood out as priorities to them:

Mechanical Ventilation (5) – MH, GT, RM, JT, VF

Thermographic Cameras (3) – MH, GT, VF

Whole House Performance Testing (2) – RM, JT

Quality of Building Materials in new construction (1) – JT

Smoking in Multi-Unit Housing (1) – TT

Promote Resident Actions (1) – VF

 

 

SF Housing Types

City Funded (CDBG)        

Federally Funded (SFHA)          

Private

Owner Occupied                       

Tenant Occupied

Issues

OAQ        

IAQ

Strategies to address housing

Code Enforcement        

Legislation/Resolution   

Tenant Education

 

 

 

        All members should read through grid thoroughly and come to next meeting with 2-3 top issues they feel are important.  At next

 

        Is there anyone else who could be joining us at our next meeting(s)?

        All will review and send top 3 priorities with some explanation.

Once we look at this we should consider costs – need some support to do that.

        Add an extra column for costs/funding so we can analyze that as well

        Anjali will email WHPT info, Ray will send out info on website

 

Review minutes last meeting & any tasks over next 30 days that have not been addressed yet

 

·          

Review expectations & assignments for next meeting; confirm next meeting date & agenda

 

·          

Announcements

 

·