(DISCUSSION) Chief’s report. The Chief introduced two new POs (Vivian Green, Lorena Darez), who gave a brief introduction of themselves.
He reported that a committee has been established to further the protocols for naming spaces in juvenile hall, the next meeting being May 15.
He reported that they have been doing many things to assure the quality of life in juvenile hall vis-a-vis the increased numbers, and have put more administrative oversight on the day-to-day activities in the hall.
They have been discussing the issue with other partners (court, DA, PD, etc) to understand the impact of the situation, and the CBOs involved with detention alternative programs. Efforts are being made to intensively review and expedite cases. Encouragement is being given to police to cite and release, or refer to CARC rather than admitting to JH. (the full written report is attached)
Comm Fetiçō asked why these problems have not been resolved now, 2 yrs after coming here (having acknowledged the problem before), when the commission has indicated its concern for this early on. The Chief said that many things were out of his control. He’s had to understand the level of work and training of the POs, the practices of the courts and officers, the reduced resources within the dept, and the lack of support for JDAI, that he was led to believe existed here. The recent crisis in population has called forward the stakeholders to try and address it.
Comm Woodson asked if they had analyzed why there was a spike in crimes (eg robbery) by Afr/Am youth in the Bayview Hunters Point community. She asked if various scenarios were the cause, and the Chief echoed those as situations, which lead to over detention.
Comm Rojas asked how many of the youth brought to YGC are from crimes committed at schools. There was no definite number available at the meeting.
(public comment)
A rep from the Mission Neighborhood Center asked if there could be a private place in juvenile hall that confidential conversations could be held between detainees and service providers? There used to be. The Chief said he’d look into it.
Another speaker asked what is being done to get more alternative placement beds at culturally competent organizations. The Chief said there is a plan to deal with the closure of Walden House. As to needs of undocumented youth, the Dept cannot solve that problem by itself.
Denise Coleman, CARC, commented that there still is a disparity between charges and actual violations, which result in youth being detained in juvenile hall rather than being dealt with through CARC. Her other concern was about violations of probation which bring youth back into juvenile hall needlessly.
Another rep from Mission Neighborhood Center (MNC) was concerned about the practice of co-ed detention (having males and females in the same unit). The Chief said it is a staffing issue. He said it wont happen again.
Barbara Ross, DPO, expressed her concern over the aggressive and arbitrary charging of youth for crimes that are more serious than they really are. (eg. youth with bb guns charged with weapons violations. Whereas youth with brass knuckles are not detained). There are many younger youth being charged and held in juvenile hall.
Vanessa, MNC, spoke about the needs of kids who are long-term cases, and how they want to find more resources in the community to serve them. This includes the undocumented youth.
She also was unhappy about the attitudes of some court officers toward CBOs when they come to court.
Tenish Smith, a caseworker at MNC expressed disappointment that they have only gotten 11 referrals from the Dept for their program, this program year.
Claudia, coordinator of an ERC asked that a PO be assigned to the ERC again, as once was the case. The Chief said that this was part of the model that he had in Chicago and thought was going to be here.
Tracy Brown presented recommendations from the juvenile justice providers association that addressed the overcrowding issue at juvenile hall.
“House review” including participation from juvenile justice providers association.
Establishing procedures re: probation violations, alternative services
Utilizing shelters
Police overcharging
Refusing to intake youth without a police report
Arturo, Columbia Park Boys/Girls Club expressed disappointment that referrals from the Dept to their program have been few (14 out of 59).
The Chief said that he is looking toward the organizational development under the Zellerbach grant to restore this relationship, and will involve community in the planning for it.
He acknowledged the letter they sent him and said he has already instructed the probation services that any case supervision will include some utilization of community based services.
Damone Hale commented that much of the upswing in juvenile population is due to police overcharging and judges detaining. He said that the impression that MOCJ is spurring a “rebirth” of interest in JDAI is crap. He said that City Hall has always been at the table when JDAI was being developed here, and known what it takes to keep kids out of juvenile hall. But they don’t have concrete evaluations of effectiveness in community programs, and judges have no confidence to send kids to them.
Abrahim, Inner City Youth, spoke in support of transitional housing and fixing LCRS.
Another speaker expressed his disappointment at all stakeholders for the continued failing of the system to keep numbers of youth out of detention. He spoke about the community peace plan that has many ideas that should be implemented, and has been discussing it in the Latino community to see how it can be adapted to their needs. He encouraged the Dept and Commission to explore it more intently.
|