Agenda* / Notice of Assessment Appeals Board
Assessment Appeals Board 1 Hearing
Room 406, City Hall
Tuesday, October 19, 2010
9:30 AM (ALL DAY)
Under the California Constitution and applicable statutes, hearings of the Assessment Appeals Board are judicial proceedings. The decisions of Assessment Appeals Boards must be based exclusively on properly admitted evidence. Assessment Appeals Boards may not base any factual determinations necessary for their decisions on anything other than the aforementioned evidence. Information presented through public comment, unless properly admitted into evidence in compliance with the Revenue and Taxation code and the Property Tax Rules of the State Board of Equalization, is not evidence upon which Assessment Appeals Boards may base findings.
The Assessment Appeals Board Agenda packet and documents are available for review in Room 405 at City Hall. Each item on the Agenda may include the following documents: (1) An Application for Changed Assessment (2)
Comparable Sale Information (3) Department or Agency Correspondence (4) Public Correspondence.
Public comment will be taken for items on the agenda, as well as items not on the agenda but under the jurisdiction of the Board. Each person wishing to speak on an item before the Board shall be permitted to be heard once for up to three minutes.
1) Public comment* (For all items on the agenda, as well as items not on the agenda, but under the jurisdiction of the Board.)
2) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-0928
APPLICANT: BIRCH, MICHAEL
PARCEL NO.: 0962 008D
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0037 RAYCLIFF TER,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $29,000,000.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $12,000,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: BASE YEAR
3) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-2088
APPLICANT: PAREKH, KADAMBARI
PARCEL NO.: 0996 027
PARCEL ADDRESS: 3441 WASHINGTON ST,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $6,435,719.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $5,500,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
4) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-2546
APPLICANT: NGUYEN, CINDY
PARCEL NO.: 5428F035
PARCEL ADDRESS: 1991 ARMSTRONG AVE,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $585,159.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $475,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
5) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-2646
APPLICANT: POLIN, ALAN
PARCEL NO.: 0599 094
PARCEL ADDRESS: 2040 FRANKLIN ST, 1204
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $817,130.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $663,330.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
6) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-2742
APPLICANT: STEVENS, ELIZABETH
PARCEL NO.: 0989 026
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0101 MAPLE ST,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $3,974,327.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $3,012,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
7) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-2957
APPLICANT: HEI SAN FRANCISCO, LLC
PARCEL NO.: 0229 020
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0375 BATTERY ST,
TOPIC: Decline in Value
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $142,892,546.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $42,878,764.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Both Real & Personal Prty
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
STATUS: WITHDRAWN
8) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-3005
APPLICANT: SOUTH MARKET, LLC
PARCEL NO.: 3750 089
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0339 - 0349 SAINT FRANCIS PL,
TOPIC: Decline in Value
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $176,867,999.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $121,000,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
STATUS: POSTPONED
9) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-3206
APPLICANT: GAP, INC.
PARCEL NO.: 3741 035
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0002 FOLSOM ST,
TOPIC: Decline in Value
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $195,483,565.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $88,000,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
STATUS: POSTPONED
10) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-3834
APPLICANT: FOUR UNITS LLC
PARCEL NO.: 0351 063
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0083 MCALLISTER ST,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $275,400.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $180,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
11) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-3838
APPLICANT: KOBE, LEIGH ANNE
PARCEL NO.: 0351 108
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0083 MCALLISTER ST,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $518,118.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $395,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
12) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-3840
APPLICANT: FOUR UNITS LLC
PARCEL NO.: 0351 073
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0083 MCALLISTER ST,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $275,400.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $180,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
13) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-3842
APPLICANT: FOUR UNITS LLC
PARCEL NO.: 0351 066
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0083 MCALLISTER ST,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $275,400.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $180,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
14) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-3843
APPLICANT: FOUR UNITS LLC
PARCEL NO.: 0351 099
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0083 - 0091 MCALLISTER ST,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $275,400.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $180,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
15) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-3890
APPLICANT: SLATT, ROBERT
PARCEL NO.: 0599 207
PARCEL ADDRESS: 1701 JACKSON ST#508 ,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $860,000.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $775,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
16) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-4246
APPLICANT: KIM, ERIC
PARCEL NO.: 0572 045
PARCEL ADDRESS: 1440 BROADWAY , 205
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $809,950.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $725,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
17) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-4649
APPLICANT: LAWTON, MADELEINE
PARCEL NO.: 0572 059
PARCEL ADDRESS: 1440 BROADWAY , #405
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $869,126.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $740,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
18) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-4754
APPLICANT: MAIO ROMO TRUST
PARCEL NO.: 0584 019
PARCEL ADDRESS: 2511 BROADWAY ,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $5,682,767.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $3,000,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
19) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-5078
APPLICANT: HEIMBERGER, ANN
PARCEL NO.: 0599 274
PARCEL ADDRESS: 1800 WASHINGTON ST #913 ,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $961,196.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $765,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
20) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-6461
APPLICANT: LEE, SALLY
PARCEL NO.: 0985 020
PARCEL ADDRESS: 3325 JACKSON ST,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $3,770,000.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $2,860,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2008
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: SUPPLEMENTAL
KNOW YOUR RIGHTS UNDER THE SUNSHINE ORDINANCE
Government's duty is to serve the public, reaching it's decision in full view of the public. Commissions, boards, councils and other agencies of the City and County exist to conduct the people's business. This ordinance assures that deliberations are conducted before the people and the City operations are open to the people's review.
For more information on your rights under the Sunshine Ordinance (Chapter 67 of the San Francisco Administrative Code) or to report a violation of the ordinance, contact the Administrator by mail to: Sunshine Ordinance Task Force, 1 Dr. Carlton B. Goodlett Place, Room 244, San Francisco, CA 94102-4689; by phone at 415.554.7724, by fax at 415.554.7854, or by e-mail at sotf@sfgov.org.
Citizens interested in obtaining a free copy of the Sunshine Ordinance can request a copy from the Administrator or by printing Chapter 67 of the San Francisco Administrative Code from the Internet, at http://www.sfgov.org/sunshine/
Lobbyist Registration and Reporting Requirements
Individuals and entities that influence or attempt to influence local legislative or administrative action may be required by the San Francisco Lobbyist Ordinance [SF Campaign & Governmental Conduct Code § 2.100] to register and report
lobbying activity. For more information about the Lobbyist Ordinance, please contact the San Francisco Ethics Commission at 30 Van Ness Avenue, Suite 3900, San Francisco, CA 94102; telephone (415) 581-2300; fax (415) 581-2317; Web Site Disability Access – The hearing room is wheelchair accessible.
* Public comment will be taken on every item on the agenda.
Agenda* / Notice of Assessment Appeals Board
Assessment Appeals Board 1 Hearing
Room 406, City Hall
Tuesday, October 19, 2010
1:30 PM
Under the California Constitution and applicable statutes, hearings of the Assessment Appeals Board are judicial proceedings. The decisions of Assessment Appeals Boards must be based exclusively on properly admitted evidence. Assessment Appeals Boards may not base any factual determinations necessary for their decisions on anything other than the aforementioned evidence. Information presented through public comment, unless properly admitted into evidence in compliance with the Revenue and Taxation code and the Property Tax Rules of the State Board of Equalization, is not evidence upon which Assessment Appeals Boards may base findings.
The Assessment Appeals Board Agenda packet and documents are available for review in Room 405 at City Hall. Each item on the Agenda may include the following documents: (1) An Application for Changed Assessment (2)
Comparable Sale Information (3) Department or Agency Correspondence (4) Public Correspondence.
Public comment will be taken for items on the agenda, as well as items not on the agenda but under the jurisdiction of the Board. Each person wishing to speak on an item before the Board shall be permitted to be heard once for up to three minutes.
1) Public comment* (For all items on the agenda, as well as items not on the agenda, but under the jurisdiction of the Board.)
2) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-2112
APPLICANT: KANOUSE, GARNET
PARCEL NO.: 1269 220
PARCEL ADDRESS: 2380 - 2400 DOWNEY ST,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $1,258,883.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $808,600.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
3) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-2177
APPLICANT: ZHU, XING YI
PARCEL NO.: 6165 049
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0075 DELTA ST,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $717,648.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $500,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
4) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-2361
APPLICANT: MAKAROVSKY, VALERIE
PARCEL NO.: 1195 023
PARCEL ADDRESS: 1924 HAYES ST, #2
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $640,000.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $566,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: ROLL CORRECTION
5) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-2463
APPLICANT: MURRAY, JAMES
PARCEL NO.: 1043 028
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0016 0018 IRIS AVE,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $1,903,932.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $1,600,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
6) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-3037
APPLICANT: YANG, INJA
PARCEL NO.: 1333 045
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0195 25TH AVE, 102
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $1,014,498.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $800,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
7) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-3141
APPLICANT: FANG, LUCETTE
PARCEL NO.: 1383 058
PARCEL ADDRESS: 6120 CALIFORNIA ST,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $851,700.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $720,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
8) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-3815
APPLICANT: ZAHEDANI, AARON
PARCEL NO.: 2607 179
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0355 BUENA VISTA EAST AVE, 505W
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $575,000.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $550,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: ROLL CORRECTION
9) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-3877
APPLICANT: SCHENEWERK, JOYCE
PARCEL NO.: 2610 059
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0027 DIVISADERO ST,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $1,144,440.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $975,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
10) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-4039
APPLICANT: FOX-SANCHEZ, SUSAN
PARCEL NO.: 1383 056
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0240 24TH AVE,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $1,175,040.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $881,280.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
11) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-4066
APPLICANT: LEVY, BENJAMIN
PARCEL NO.: 1361 075
PARCEL ADDRESS: 3905 CALIFORNIA ST,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $2,288,880.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $1,876,882.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
12) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-4102
APPLICANT: EPSTEIN, JONATHON
PARCEL NO.: 1081 048
PARCEL ADDRESS: 2549 POST ST, #3
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $1,402,458.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $900,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
13) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-4138
APPLICANT: STROH, FRANCES
PARCEL NO.: 1363 010
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0137 03RD AVE,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $2,505,157.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $2,100,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
14) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-4784
APPLICANT: MORRIS, STEPHEN
PARCEL NO.: 1536 052
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0439 8TH AVE, #1
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $1,027,914.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $950,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
15) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-6226
APPLICANT: SABARESE, SEAN
PARCEL NO.: 1049 073
PARCEL ADDRESS: 2715 PINE ST,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $1,342,116.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $1,174,550.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2009
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: ESCAPE
16) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2009-6246
APPLICANT: SABARESE, SEAN
PARCEL NO.: 1049 073
PARCEL ADDRESS: 2715 PINE ST,
TOPIC: To consider written stipulation agreement
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $1,315,800.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $1,160,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2008
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: ESCAPE
KNOW YOUR RIGHTS UNDER THE SUNSHINE ORDINANCE
Government's duty is to serve the public, reaching it's decision in full view of the public. Commissions, boards, councils and other agencies of the City and County exist to conduct the people's business. This ordinance assures that deliberations are conducted before the people and the City operations are open to the people's review.
For more information on your rights under the Sunshine Ordinance (Chapter 67 of the San Francisco Administrative Code) or to report a violation of the ordinance, contact the Administrator by mail to: Sunshine Ordinance Task Force, 1 Dr. Carlton B. Goodlett Place, Room 244, San Francisco, CA 94102-4689; by phone at 415.554.7724, by fax at 415.554.7854, or by e-mail at sotf@sfgov.org.
Citizens interested in obtaining a free copy of the Sunshine Ordinance can request a copy from the Administrator or by printing Chapter 67 of the San Francisco Administrative Code from the Internet, at http://www.sfgov.org/sunshine/
Lobbyist Registration and Reporting Requirements
Individuals and entities that influence or attempt to influence local legislative or administrative action may be required by the San Francisco Lobbyist Ordinance [SF Campaign & Governmental Conduct Code § 2.100] to register and report
lobbying activity. For more information about the Lobbyist Ordinance, please contact the San Francisco Ethics Commission at 30 Van Ness Avenue, Suite 3900, San Francisco, CA 94102; telephone (415) 581-2300; fax (415) 581-2317; Web Site Disability Access – The hearing room is wheelchair accessible.
* Public comment will be taken on every item on the agenda.