September 20, 2007

JOURNAL OF PROCEEDINGS

CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO

ASSESSMENT APPEALS BOARD

In the meeting of Assessment Appeals Board Number 1 for the City and County of San Francisco on Thursday, September 20, 2007, at 10:00 a.m.

Present: Peter Fatooh, Diane Robinson and Carol Ruth Silver

Quorum present

Chairperson: Carol Ruth Silver, Presiding

Deputy City Attorney, Marie Blits

Certified Court Reporter, Maryann Valenoti

The following listed applicant for change in the assessed valuation of property affecting various years of the assessment roll being present and heard, the Board continued to hear Applicant's cross-examination of the Assessor. The Board took certain action, as specified under this date, on the original of the respective applications:

Appeal No.	Name	Disposition
2002-1240	Clift Holdings, LLC	Continued to 1:15 p.m.
2005-0532	Clift Holdings, LLC	Continued
2005-0533	Clift Holdings, LLC	Continued
2005-0534	Clift Holdings, LLC	Continued

The following listed applicants for change in the assessed valuation of property affecting the Assessment Roll for various years having not been present for hearing as scheduled, the Board took no action, as specified under this date, on the original of the respective applications:

Appeal No.	Name	Disposition
2006-0224	Florence K. Mack Estate	Postponed
2006-0225	Florence K. Mack Estate	Postponed
2006-0747	Florence K. Mack Estate	Postponed
2006-0748	Florence K. Mack Estate	Postponed
2006-0749	Florence K. Mack Estate	Postponed
2006-0750	Florence K. Mack Estate	Postponed
2006-1285	Prabhaben Patel	Withdrawn
2006-1286	Prabhaben Patel	Withdrawn
2006-1289	Prabhaben Patel	Withdrawn
2006-1290	Prabhaben Patel	Withdrawn

RECESS

The Board, at the hour of 12:03 p.m., recessed to reconvene at 1:15 p.m.

RECONVENING OF THE BOARD

The Assessment Appeals Board reconvened at the hour of 1:20 p.m.

Present: Peter Fatooh, Diane Robinson and Carol Ruth Silver

Quorum present

Chairperson: Carol Ruth Silver, Presiding

Deputy City Attorney, Marie Blits

Certified Court Reporter, Maryann Valenoti

With the same parties present from the morning session, the Board continued hearing Applicant's cross-examination of the Assessor, followed by the Assessor's redirect testimony. The Board then heard rebuttal testimony from Applicant's appraiser, Patrick Chambers. The Board took certain action, as specified under this date, on the original of the respective applications:

Appeal No.	Name	Disposition
2002-1240	Clift Holdings, LLC	Continued to 9/24/07
2005-0532	Clift Holdings, LLC	Continued to 9/24/07
2005-0533	Clift Holdings, LLC	Continued to 9/24/07
2005-0534	Clift Holdings, LLC	Continued to 9/24/07

There being no further business, the Board, at the hour of 3:41 p.m., recessed to reconvene Friday, September 21, 2007, at 9:30 a.m.

Angela Calvillo

Clerk

Dawn Duran

Administrator

Approved by the Board October 12, 2007