Agenda* / Notice of Assessment Appeals Board
Assessment Appeals Board 2 Hearing
Room 406, City Hall
Tuesday, February 19, 2013
1:30 PM

Under the California Constitution and applicable statutes, hearings of the Assessment Appeals Board are judicial proceedings. The decisions of Assessment Appeals Boards must be based exclusively on properly admitted evidence. Assessment Appeals Boards may not base any factual determinations necessary for their decisions on anything other than the aforementioned evidence. Information presented through public comment, unless properly admitted into evidence in compliance with the Revenue and Taxation code and the Property Tax Rules of the State Board of Equalization, is not evidence upon which Assessment Appeals Boards may base findings.

The Assessment Appeals Board Agenda packet and documents are available for review in Room 405 at City Hall. Each item on the Agenda may include the following documents: (1) An Application for Changed Assessment (2) Comparable Sale Information (3) Department or Agency Correspondence (4) Public Correspondence.

Public comment will be taken for items on the agenda, as well as items not on the agenda but under the jurisdiction of the Board. Each person wishing to speak on an item before the Board shall be permitted to be heard once for up to three minutes.

1) Public comment* (For all items on the agenda, as well as items not on the agenda, but under the jurisdiction
of the Board.)

2) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2011-3893
APPLICANT: GRANT, SCOTT
PARCEL NO.: 3961 006
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0354 - 0358 UTAH ST,
TOPIC: Decline in Value
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $1,977,116.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $1,300,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2011
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR

3) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2011-3904
APPLICANT: SAVE MART
PARCEL NO.: 1175 031
PARCEL ADDRESS: 1780 - 1790 FULTON ST,
TOPIC: Decline in Value
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $7,320,248.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $5,000,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2011
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR

4) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2011-3906
APPLICANT: SAVE MART
PARCEL NO.: 1175 168
PARCEL ADDRESS: 1750 FULTON ST,
TOPIC: Decline in Value
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $20,013,926.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $15,353,830.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2011
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR

5) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2011-3908
APPLICANT: SAVE MART
PARCEL NO.: 7255 002
PARCEL ADDRESS: 1595 SLOAT BLVD,
TOPIC: Decline in Value
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $27,827,955.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $20,533,884.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2011
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
STATUS: WITHDRAWN

6) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2011-4064
APPLICANT: NGUYEN, ISABELLE
PARCEL NO.: 2381 042
PARCEL ADDRESS: 2414 45TH AVE,
TOPIC: Decline in Value
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $680,000.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $579,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2011
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
STATUS: POSTPONED

7) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2011-4090
APPLICANT: KHAVUL, MIKHAIL
PARCEL NO.: 1753 001
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0301 HUGO ST,
TOPIC: Decline in Value
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $1,610,496.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $1,400,370.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2011
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR

8) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2011-4091
APPLICANT: KHAVUL, MIKHAIL
PARCEL NO.: 1230 019
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0532 COLE ST,
TOPIC: Decline in Value
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $1,819,808.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $1,550,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2011
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR

9) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2011-4092
APPLICANT: KHAVUL, MIKHAIL
PARCEL NO.: 1379 034A
PARCEL ADDRESS: 1845 LAKE ST,
TOPIC: Decline in Value
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $1,854,420.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $1,600,780.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2011
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR

10) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:

APPLICATION: 2011-4113
APPLICANT: KU, CHRISTINA
PARCEL NO.: 3995 123
PARCEL ADDRESS: 2030 3RD ST, UNIT 19
TOPIC: Decline in Value
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $804,178.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $680,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2011
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR

11) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2011-4115
APPLICANT: ALMAS, ERIK
PARCEL NO.: 1219 059
PARCEL ADDRESS: 1110 PAGE ST,
TOPIC: Decline in Value
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $1,340,000.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $890,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2011
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR

12) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2011-4140
APPLICANT: DONAHUE, RICHARD
PARCEL NO.: 2979 012
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0820 - 0824 ULLOA ST,
TOPIC: Decline in Value
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $1,386,503.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $800,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2011
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
STATUS: WITHDRAWN

13) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2011-4143
APPLICANT: DONAHUE, RICHARD
PARCEL NO.: 2979 013
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0840 - 0850 ULLOA ST,
TOPIC: Decline in Value
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $1,279,851.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $800,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2011
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR
STATUS: WITHDRAWN

14) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2011-4176
APPLICANT: NAHRGANG, JONATHAN
PARCEL NO.: 1352 040
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0069 06TH AVE,
TOPIC: Decline in Value
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $1,333,330.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $1,200,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2011
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR

15) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2011-4181
APPLICANT: BEDIKIAN, ARTHUR
PARCEL NO.: 6148 008
PARCEL ADDRESS: 0844 DARTMOUTH ST,
TOPIC: Decline in Value
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $620,000.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $575,000.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2011
APPEAL TYPE: Real Property
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR

16) Hearing, discussion, and possible action involving:
APPLICATION: 2011-4247
APPLICANT: LEE, JOHN
PARCEL NO.: 1649 012
PARCEL ADDRESS: 3030 - 3032 FULTON ST,
TOPIC: Decline in Value
CURRENT ASSESSMENT: $1,389,668.00
APPLICANT'S OPINION: $1,051,500.00
TAXABLE YEAR: 2011
APPEAL TYPE: Both Real & Personal Prty
ROLL TYPE: REGULAR

KNOW YOUR RIGHTS UNDER THE SUNSHINE ORDINANCE
Government's duty is to serve the public, reaching it's decision in full view of the public. Commissions, boards, councils and other agencies of the City and County exist to conduct the people's business. This ordinance assures that deliberations are conducted before the people and the City operations are open to the people's review.

For more information on your rights under the Sunshine Ordinance (Chapter 67 of the San Francisco Administrative Code) or to report a violation of the ordinance, contact the Administrator by mail to: Sunshine Ordinance Task Force, 1 Dr. Carlton B. Goodlett Place, Room 244, San Francisco, CA 94102-4689; by phone at 415.554.7724, by fax at 415.554.7854, or by e-mail at sotf@sfgov.org.

Citizens interested in obtaining a free copy of the Sunshine Ordinance can request a copy from the Administrator or by printing Chapter 67 of the San Francisco Administrative Code from the Internet, at http://www.sfgov.org/sunshine/

Lobbyist Registration and Reporting Requirements
Individuals and entities that influence or attempt to influence local legislative or administrative action may be required by the San Francisco Lobbyist Ordinance [SF Campaign & Governmental Conduct Code § 2.100] to register and report lobbying activity. For more information about the Lobbyist Ordinance, please contact the San Francisco Ethics Commission at 30 Van Ness Avenue, Suite 3900, San Francisco, CA 94102; telephone (415) 581-2300; fax (415) 581-2317; Web Site www.sfgov.org/ethics.

Disability Access – The hearing room is wheelchair accessible.

* Public comment will be taken on every item on the agenda.