SAN FRANCISCO

PLANNING COMMISSION

AND

RECREATION & PARK

COMMISSION

 

 

Meeting Minutes

 

 

 

 

Room 400

City Hall, 1 Dr. Carlton B. Goodlett Place

San Francisco, CA 94102-4689

 

 

Thursday, December 15, 2016

1:00 p.m.

                             

PLANNING COMMISSIONERS PRESENT:                    Fong, Richards, Hillis, Johnson, Koppel, Melgar, Moore

 

RECREATION & PARK COMMISSIONERS PRESENT:                                        Buell, Bonilla, Low, Anderson, Harrison, McDonnell

 

 

THE MEETING WAS CALLED TO ORDER BY PRESIDENT FONG AT 1:07 PM

 

STAFF IN ATTENDANCE:         Melinda Hue, John Rahaim – Planning Director, and Jonas P. Ionin – Commission Secretary

 

 

A.               SPECIAL CALENDAR

 

NOTE: The Joint Commissions will hold one public hearing for the public to provide testimony on all items listed below.  Following the public hearing, the Planning Commission will consider certifying the Final EIR for the Natural Resource Management Plan (formerly named Significant Natural Resources Area Management Plan or SNRAMP); and the Recreation and Park Commission will consider adopting the CEQA findings for the Plan and will then consider approving the Plan.

1a.          2005.0912E                                                                                          (M. HUE: (415) 575-9041)

SIGNIFICANT NATURAL RESOURCE AREAS MANAGEMENT PLAN -  Certification of the Final

Environmental Impact Report - The proposed project is the Natural Resource Management Plan (formerly named Significant Natural Resources Area Management Plan or SNRAMP). The Natural Resource Management Plan (NRMP) contains detailed information on the biology, geology, and trails within 32 Natural Areas, 31 of which are in San Francisco and one (Sharp Park) is in Pacifica. The NRMP is intended to guide natural resource protection, habitat restoration, trail and access improvements, other capital projects, and maintenance activities over the next 20 years.

NOTE: The public hearing on the Draft EIR is closed. The public comment period for the Draft EIR ended on June 11, 2012. Public comment will be received when the item is called during the hearing. However, comments submitted may not be included in the Final EIR.

Preliminary Recommendation: Certify the Final EIR

(Planning Commission Action Only)

SPEAKERS:          = Melinda Hue – Staff Report

+ Chris Giorni - SNRAMP

+ Christopher Campbell - SNRAMP

-     Bridget Kelly - SNRAMP

+ Charlotte Hill  - SNRAMP

= Arthur Feinstein - SNRAMP

+ Mercus Griswald - SNRAMP

+ Amber Hasselbring - SNRAMP

+ Bill Brick - SNRAMP

+ Richard Harris - SNRAMP

-     Linda Garcia Milhoan - SNRAMP

+ Brian Penkins - SNRAMP

+ Greg Gaar - SNRAMP

+ Josiah Clark - SNRAMP

+ Terri Thomas - SNRAMP

+ Mike Wallash - SNRAMP

-     Connie Cykman - SNRAMP

-     Agustin LaRue - SNRAMP

-     Julie Gallegos - SNRAMP

+ Mary Pedraza - SNRAMP

+ Patrick Rump - SNRAMP

+ William Murphy - SNRAMP

+ Mary Tienken - SNRAMP

-     Alex Cuadra - SNRAMP

= Julia Frank - SNRAMP

= Neal Desai - SNRAMP

+ Jay Watson - SNRAMP

-     Tom Borden - SNRAMP

+ Llirik Povolotsking - SNRAMP

+ Dan Flanagan - SNRAMP

+ Amy Wolfrum - SNRAMP

+ Arielle Fleisher - SNRAMP

+ Rachel Norton - SNRAMP

-     Cindy Margulia - SNRAMP

+ Linda Shaffer - SNRAMP

+ Patricia Delgado - SNRAMP

+ Gloria Koch - SNRAMP

+ Amy Kaeser - SNRAMP

+ Sasha Magee - SNRAMP

+ Mathew Blain - SNRAMP

+ Kevin Yeaman - SNRAMP

+ Alicia Noyola - SNRAMP

+ Erik Rosegard - SNRAMP

= Rose Braz - SNRAMP

= Melissa Yu - SNRAMP

+ Sally Ross - SNRAMP

+ Elaine Harris - SNRAMP

-     Buffy Francisco - SNRAMP

+ Arnold Thompson - SNRAMP

+ Damien Raffa - SNRAMP

+ Susan Strolis - SNRAMP

-     Rae Bordua - SNRAMP

+ Eva Kuczynski - SNRAMP

-     Carol Borden-Gomez - SNRAMP

-     Ariane Eroy - SNRAMP

+ Dylan Hayes - SNRAMP

-     Zachary Bron - SNRAMP

-     Erin Caughman - SNRAMP

-     Rupa Bose - SNRAMP

-     Janet Kessler - SNRAMP

-     Dee Seligman - SNRAMP

-     Sally Stephens  - SNRAMP

-     Ron Proctor - SNRAMP

-     Jacquie Proctor - SNRAMP - SNRAMP

= Nadine Weil  - SNRAMP

+ Allison McCarthy - SNRAMP

+ Carlos Minaya - SNRAMP

-     Lisa Dollar – SNRAMP

-     Garrett Star - SNRAMP

-     Hannah Sawyer - SNRAMP

-     Brent Plater - SNRAMP

= Aaron Frank - SNRAMP

+ Jake Sigg - SNRAMP

+ Denise Louie - SNRAMP

+ Shelley Arnold - SNRAMP

+ Rachel Kesel - SNRAMP

-     Catherine Rubyne - SNRAMP

-     Nancy Wuerfel - SNRAMP

-     Dennis Hall  - SNRAMP

+ Maddie Duda - SNRAMP

+ Kirra Swenerton  - SNRAMP

= Rosalind Lord - SNRAMP

+ Matt Juvagler - SNRAMP

-     Gretchen Logue - SNRAMP

+ John Burns - SNRAMP

+ Paul Slavin - SNRAMP

+ Randy Zebell- SNRAMP

-     Timothy Armoun - SNRAMP

+ Rupert Clayton - SNRAMP

-     Janer Mauckly - SNRAMP

-     Jeffrey Gallegos - SNRAMP

= Eva Del Campo - SNRAMP

-     Roger Lote - SNRAMP

+ Annie M. - SNRAMP

+ Rachel Carter - SNRAMP

-     ___ Kubitz - SNRAMP

= Kate Edwards - SNRAMP

-     Frank J. Triska - SNRAMP

-     Victoria Hamman - SNRAMP

-     Stan Zeavin - SNRAMP

-     Victor Carmichael - SNRAMP

-     Margaret Goodale - SNRAMP

-     Ron Maykel - SNRAMP

+ Kenny Lange - SNRAMP

+ Michael Safyan - SNRAMP

-     Steve Shorb - SNRAMP

+ Frank Sicignano - SNRAMP

-     Michael Balea - SNRAMP

-     Costanza Foran - SNRAMP

-     Marshall Dinowitz - SNRAMP

-     Katherine Button - SNRAMP

-     Jerry Risk - SNRAMP

-     Jane Risk - SNRAMP

-     Mark Mushkat - SNRAMP

-     Brian Har - SNRAMP

-     Alfred Luongo - SNRAMP

-     Ossie Gomez - SNRAMP

-     Robert Gee - SNRAMP

+ Peter Brastow - SNRAMP

-     Karen Breslin - SNRAMP

-     Jack Gescheidt - SNRAMP

+ Doug Wildman - SNRAMP

-     Kathleen Ramos - SNRAMP

-     Stephen Hall - SNRAMP

-     Till Fehrenbacher - SNRAMP

-     Neal Desai - SNRAMP

-     Eric Brooks - SNRAMP

                                                            = Robert Sutton               - SNRAMP

= Dede Moriary - SNRAMP

+ Deidre Martin - SNRAMP

= Glenn Rogers - SNRAMP

-     Peter Jones - SNRAMP

-     Paul Drexler - SNRAMP

-     David Hover - SNRAMP

+ Palou-Phelps Park - SNRAMP

= Paul Rotter - SNRAMP

-     Irina Kenderova - SNRAMP

+ Mie Yaginum - SNRAMP

-     Augusta Goldstein - SNRAMP                                

-     John Munz - SNRAMP

+ Ellen Price - SNRAMP

+ Bob Siegel - SNRAMP

= Vic Milhoan - SNRAMP

ACTION:                              To Certify the FEIR

AYES:                    Fong, Richards, Hillis,Johnson Johnson, Koppel, Melgar

NAYES:                 Moore

MOTION:              19825

1b.                                                                                                                  (S. BRADLEY (415) 575-5609)

NATURAL RESOURCE MANAGEMENT PLAN - Discussion and possible action to adopt CEQA Findings, and approve the Natural Resources Management Plan (formerly named Significant Natural Resources Area Management Plan or SNRAMP). Approval of this proposed action by the Commission is the Approval Action as defined by S.F. Administrative Code Chapter 31.

(Recreation & Park Commission Action Only)

 

Adjournment – 7:27 P.M.

ADOPTE: JANUARY 5, 2017